Sunday, November 26, 2006

Brian Flemming Post


This is from Brian Flemming's blog (author of the god who wasn't there).

The stupidity

It burns. Proceed at your own risk.

Example (condensed from the original):

SAM HARRIS: Even if your claim about the link between faith and morality were true, it would offer no support whatsoever for your religious beliefs. Even if atheism led straight to moral chaos, this would not suggest that the doctrine of Judaism is true. Islam might be true in that case. Or all religions might function like placebos. As descriptions of the universe, they could be utterly false but extraordinarily useful.

DENNIS PRAGER: You are right that this moral clarity and courage among the predominantly religious does not prove the existence of the biblical God. Nothing can prove God’s existence. But it sure is a powerful argument. If society cannot survive without x, there is a good chance x exists.

SAM HARRIS: No, Dennis, this moral clarity is not a “powerful argument,” or even an argument at all; please keep your x’s straight. If humanity can’t survive without a belief in God, this would only mean that a belief in God exists. It wouldn’t, even remotely, suggest that God exists.
DENNIS PRAGER: It is hard for me to imagine that any fair-minded reader would reach the same conclusion. If we both acknowledge that without belief in God humanity would self-destruct, it is quite a stretch to say that this fact does not “even remotely suggest that God exists.” Can you name one thing that does not exist but is essential to human survival?
I know, I just gave your eyes third-degree burns. I warned you.


Is there a word for this phenomenon of relatively intelligent people being suddenly unable to use their brains in the face of an obviously valid point? Oh, wait, I just remembered. It's called religion.

But is there a word for the phenomenon of people in the public eye making such extraordinarily stupid statements and still keeping their audience? Oh, wait, I just remembered. It's called talk radio.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi all!

Our group propose you to include WEB2.0 to your site.

Thank you.


airline priceline ticket
http://priceline-airline-ticket10.mobprofile.com/airline-priceline-ticket.html
airline priceline ticket
refinance loan
http://butalbital4.mobprofile.com/refinance-loan.html
refinance loan
free online poker
http://free-online-poker6.mobprofile.com/free-online-poker.html
free online poker
free boost mobile ringtone
http://0-apr-credit-card0.mobprofile.com/free-boost-mobile-ringtone.html
free boost mobile ringtone
airfare airline orbitz ticket
http://free-online-poker6.mobprofile.com/airfare-airline-orbitz-ticket.html
airfare airline orbitz ticket
unlocked cell phone
http://free-online-poker6.mobprofile.com/unlocked-cell-phone.html
unlocked cell phone
play disney channel game online
http://2nd-mortgage8.mobprofile.com/play-disney-channel-game-online.html
play disney channel game online
**VrunGert**

Aaron said...

what is this?

Anonymous said...

Hoping that peri-menopause and the lowering of the amount of hormones in
my body will help shrink them. Have you had an ultrasound? They aren't
necessarily the emergency that lucy is implying. I have had fibroids for
15 years and mine are very slow growing. If they aren't filling your entire
uterus and causing really odd bleeding, then they are fine. Even some off
period bleeding is okay. You CAN get them lasered out. a friend
of mine did that twice. Especially if you keep them monitored...

percocet on line
http://percocet-on-line7.eco-forums.com/percocet-on-line.html
percocet on line
extrapyramidal side effects
http://mobic-side-effects3.eco-forums.com/extrapyramidal-side-effects.html
extrapyramidal side effects
diet ephedra
http://drug-pills9.eco-forums.com/diet-ephedra.html
diet ephedra
phentermine hydrochloride
http://rx-forum1.eco-forums.com/phentermine-hydrochloride.html
phentermine hydrochloride
drugs with no prescription
http://drugs-with-no-prescription5.eco-forums.com/drugs-with-no-prescription.html
drugs with no prescription
adipex phentermine
http://mexican-prescriptions10.eco-forums.com/adipex-phentermine.html
adipex phentermine
pharmacy drug store
http://pharmacy-drug-store7.eco-forums.com/pharmacy-drug-store.html
pharmacy drug store
order pills
http://adipex-purchase3.eco-forums.com/order-pills.html
order pills
phentermine tablets
http://phentermine-addiction9.eco-forums.com/phentermine-tablets.html
phentermine tablets
drug weight loss
http://medication-weight-loss1.eco-forums.com/drug-weight-loss.html
drug weight loss